You go to a new gym, or you try the other cable station in your own gym. You set the pin at 20 kg, the same weight you always use. This time the handle barely moves. It feels like you lost half your strength overnight.
You did not get weaker. The machine is different.
The hidden wheel inside some cable machines
A cable machine connects the handle to the weight stack with a steel cable. The cable runs over wheels, called pulleys. On some machines the cable goes straight from the handle, over a few fixed wheels, to the stack. On other machines the cable also runs through one extra wheel that moves together with the stack.
That extra wheel changes the job. The stack now hangs from two lines of cable instead of one, so each line carries half of the load. Your hands pull only one of those lines. This is the same idea as a pulley system on a building site, where more lines of rope let a person lift a heavy load with less force (Urone and Hinrichs, 2022).
What it means in kg
On a machine with that extra wheel, 20 kg on the stack feels like 10 kg in your hands. On a machine without it, 20 kg feels like 20 kg.
There is a trade. When the force you need goes down, the distance you pull goes up (Urone and Hinrichs, 2022). With the extra wheel, your hand travels twice as far as the stack moves. That is why some cable machines let you pull the handle a long way while the stack rises only a little.
Real pulleys are also not perfectly smooth. Old cables, worn wheels and tight bends add some friction, so two machines with the same design can still feel a little different.
So 20 kg is not the same at every gym
The number on the stack tells you which plate the pin sits in. It does not tell you how much force reaches the handle. Two machines can show the same 20 kg and give you very different work.
This is the reason your numbers can jump up or down when you change gyms or change stations. Your strength did not change between Monday and Tuesday. The machine did.
How to compare your weights
- Compare your cable weights only on the same machine.
- At a new gym, start fresh. Find the weight that gives you the same reps and the same effort as your usual sets.
- Watch the stack while you pull. If your hand moves much farther than the stack rises, that machine has an extra wheel.
- Dumbbells and barbells weigh the same in every gym, so they do not have this problem.
If you log your workouts in FORCE, you can save the gym on each workout, so you can always see where a cable weight came from.
FAQ
Is the machine that feels heavier the better one?
No. Both machines can give you hard work. The extra wheel only changes how much stack weight you need for the same effort. Pick the weight that makes the set hard for you, and compare it only with that same machine.
How can I tell if a cable machine has an extra wheel?
Pull the handle slowly and watch the weight stack. If the handle travels about twice as far as the stack moves, the stack hangs on two lines of cable. If they move the same distance, it does not.
Does this happen on other gym machines too?
Any machine that uses cables, wheels or levers can change how heavy a stack weight feels at the handle. Dumbbells and barbells do not, because nothing sits between the weight and your hands.
Sources
- Urone PP, Hinrichs R. College Physics 2e, section 9.5 "Simple Machines". OpenStax, Rice University, 2022. https://openstax.org/books/college-physics-2e/pages/9-5-simple-machines
